Brooklyn Pie Co (Reported Closed)

Recommends

pie in the sky

Joined 3 years ago

The real Brooklyn Pie Co creator. Hello , rumor has it the real Original owner (when it was real pie) .. is comming back !

From what I heard , he got mixed up with some shady partners and an embezzeling spouse .

Hope he returns with a pizza vengence , lots of luck "shaved headed pizza guru" we miss you !!

Recommends

shatter33

Joined 4 years ago

Absolutely the BEST!. I have had pizza everywhere (and I mean everywhere) and this is by far the freshest and best all around pizza you can find. There are no gimmicks, its not the cheapest, but EVERYONE we tell about it or bring it to LOVES it and every recipe on the list is great!

Most people just can't believe something this good can come from Georgetown so they have to dis it. You can KEEP YOUR AUSTIN WEIRD.

Doesn't Recommend

JessiccaS

Joined 4 years ago

This is not Brooklyn pizza, not even a lil bit!. I was born in Brooklyn & raised in Queens NY....this is not even close to NY pizza. It's horrbile! If you want pizza that is even close to NY pizza go to The Original Brooklyn Pie co (this Brooklyn pie co is not the same as the one in round rock) in Round Rock that pizza is pretty close to NY pizza the closest you'll get around here.

I tried it twice, not good at all & definately not even close to a NY pizza

Doesn't Recommend

KitchenEval

Joined 5 years ago

WE'RE HERE. Yes, Georgetown has people from Jersey, Brooklyn, Long Island and the Bronx...so it better be good pie.

It's not. They should try again maybe visit Brooklyn get some pointers and have a re-grand opening.

Recommends

iluvnillie

Joined 6 years ago

Love it!. This is great pizza! I get cravings for it. You can also get cheesecake from NY that is so good, too!

Recommends

Contributor

Joined 10 years ago

Editorial Review by Christy Buena. Specializing in authentic New York style pies and offering carry out and delivery.

Doesn't Recommend

pizzajudge007

Joined 6 years ago

Sorry, but the new owners are rude.. What ever happened to the original owners!? The bald guy with the asian wife..... That's what I get for going to Iraq.

The service used to be excellent and the food was so fresh and tasty. I hope the old owners are doing good. As for me and my friends, well we're sad they are not around anymore.

The new owner says he's some culinary chef, but whatever, and he's rude. I don't recommend this place anymore, it's not NY pizza anymore and it's not the same as before. I guess I'll be going back to Saccones - Jersey style!

Recommends

mystico

Joined 6 years ago

If you're looking for pizza outside the normal national chain realm, this place is it!!. If you want something other than the usual national chain pizza, this place rocks! They have more than the usual meat and veggie toppings--spinach, clams, feta cheese and lots of others that most "normal" places don't have. And the taste is fabulous! I almost always get the clam pizza w/white sauce (#5). It has mixture of clam oil/juice and grease on surface that makes it an even better eating experience.

I've never eaten NY-style pizza but if this is it, I'm sold! And in little Georgetown of all places. Sadly, the original owner recently sold the place. He provided excellent, personal service. He remembered customers' names and always offered a friendly smile. But the place is still da bomb!

Recommends

rodrial

Joined 9 years ago

Mr.New York City. I'm from New York City ,just to let you know this pizza is as close to having a real home made New York Pizza.Had to wait about 35 minutes for the pizza but it was worth it. Advised:Call your order ahead of time otherwise you will be wainting on your pizza.

Recommends

lesly

Joined 11 years ago

Come & Get It!. This little gem in Georgetown is making a name for itself. This is by far the BEST pizza I have ever eaten. The sauce is incredibly tasty, crust thin, portions HUGE. This is a take out only establishment, soon to open their own restaurant. It is worth the drive to pick this pie up. The owners are friendly and love their customers.